January 28, 2002
Editor
New York Times
229 West 43rd St.
New York, NY 10036-3959
Dear Editor:
We, the undersigned, representing a broad spectrum of
concerned health organizations, are responding to coverage
in your paper and the resulting public discussion
questioning the value of mammography. This discussion has
been stimulated by a recent report published in the British
medical journal, The Lancet, which concluded there
was no scientific support for breast cancer screening with
mammography.
Women and their health care professionals should know
that numerous independent expert groups in the U.S. and
Europe have repeatedly subjected the world’s major
clinical studies of mammography to careful scientific
scrutiny, and also have carefully evaluated the analysis
published in the Lancet. While the existing studies
of mammography screening have known limitations and even
some flaws, the evidence as a whole solidly supports reduced
breast cancer mortality rates due to screening mammography.
Early breast cancer detection means a greater chance for
successful treatment and a greater range of treatment
options.
We have grave concerns that these public debates have
already begun to erode the confidence in mammography that
has been built up over the past two decades. While
mammography is not a perfect tool, it is effective and has
contributed significantly to the declines in breast cancer
mortality since 1990. In fact, there will be many thousands
fewer breast cancer deaths among U.S. women this year due to
the combined progress we’ve made in early detection and
improved therapy. If women are dissuaded from getting
regular mammograms, lives will be lost.
We strongly urge women to continue to follow the advice
of their physicians and the leading medical organizations.
Our organizations will continue to monitor new scientific
research in order to offer the best advice to women and
their physicians.
This letter is cosigned by the following organizations:
American Academy of Family Physicians
American Cancer Society
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
American College of Preventive Medicine
American College of Surgeons
American Society of Clinical Oncology
Cancer Research Foundation of America
National Alliance of Breast Cancer Organizations
National Medical Association
Oncology Nursing Society
Society of Gynecological Oncology
Susan G. Komen Breast Cancer Foundation