Community Preventive Services -
Reducing Specific Diseases, Injuries and Impairments-

Vaccine-Preventable Diseases


Task Force on Community Preventive Services Recommendations:

Improving Vaccination Coverage in Children, Adolescents, and Adults

Intervention

Recommendation

Intervention Description

Increasing community demand for vaccinations

Client reminder/recall

Strongly recommended

Reminders that vaccinations are due (reminders) or late (recall) are provided to target populations.

Delivery techniques include telephone calls, letters, or postcards; contents of messages vary.

Multicomponent interventions that include education

Strongly recommended

Target populations receive education regarding vaccinations.

Vaccination providers might also receive education.

Used with at least one other activity to improve vaccination rates.

Vaccination requirements for child care, school, and college attendance

Recommended

Laws or policies are enacted or enforced that require vaccinations or other documentation of immunity as a condition of attendance.

Community-wide education only

Insufficient evidence*

Provides information to a target population in a geographic area.

Can also provide information to vaccination providers.

Does not include other features (e.g., reminders), activities, or efforts limited to specific settings.

Clinic-based education only

Insufficient evidence*

Provides information to persons served in a specific medical or public health clinical setting.

Does not include other features (e.g., reminders) or activities provided in other settings (e.g., school or child care centers).

Client or family incentives

Insufficient evidence*

Provides financial or other incentives to motivate acceptance of vaccinations.

Incentives can involve either rewards or penalties.

(Interventions with aspects of incentives (e.g., WIC programs or vaccination requirements for child care, school, or college attendance) are categorized elsewhere.)

Client-held medical records

Insufficient evidence*

Provides to clients or family members medical records that indicate which vaccinations have been received.

Enhancing access to vaccination services

Reducing out-of-pocket costs

Strongly Recommended

Can include providing free vaccinations or administration, providing insurance coverage, or reducing co-payments for vaccinations at the point of service.

Expanding access in health-care settings

As part of a multi-component intervention - Strongly recommended

Alone - Insufficient evidence

One or more of the following:

Reduces the distance from the setting to the population.

Increases or makes more convenient the hours during which vaccination services are provided.

Delivers vaccinations in clinical settings in which they were not provided previously (e.g., inpatient units).

Reduces administrative barriers to obtaining vaccination services within clinics (e.g., "drop in" clinics or an "express lane" vaccination service.

Vaccination programs in WIC settings

Recommended

Encourages the vaccination of low-income clients of this non-medical setting.

At a minimum, requires assessment of each child's immunization status and referral of under-immunized children to a health-care provider.

Home visits

Recommended

Provides face-to-face services to clients in their homes.

Services can include education, assessment of need for vaccinations, referral for vaccinations, or provision of vaccinations.

Can also include telephone or mail reminders.

Vaccination programs in schools

Insufficient evidence*

Intended to improve delivery of vaccinations to school attendees aged approximately 5-18 years.

Usually includes vaccination-related education of students, parents, teachers, and other school staff and either provision of vaccinations or referral for vaccinations.

Can also include incentives to participants and methods for acquiring written consent from parents.

(Laws requiring vaccination for school entry are evaluated elsewhere)

Vaccination programs in child-care centers

Insufficient evidence*

Encourages the vaccination of children aged <5 years.

Requires assessment of each child's immunization status at entry into child-care or at some point during child's enrollment.

Can also involve additional assessments at periodic intervals, education or notification of parents, referral of under-immunized children to a health-care provider, or provision of vaccination on-site.

(Laws requiring vaccination for child-care centers are evaluated elsewhere)

Provider-based interventions

Provider reminder/recall

Strongly recommended

Informs those who administer vaccinations that individual clients are due (reminder) or overdue (recall) for specific vaccinations.

Techniques by which reminders are delivered: client charts, computer, mail, or other; content of the reminders vary

(Interventions that incorporate elements of reminders and standing orders are reviewed with standing orders)

Assessment and feedback for vaccination providers

Strongly recommended

Involves retrospectively evaluating the performance of providers in delivering one or more vaccinations to a client population and giving this information to the providers.

Can also include other activities (e.g., incentives or benchmarking: comparing performance to a goal or standard).

Standing orders

For adults - Strongly recommended

For children - Insufficient evidence*

Non-physician medical personnel prescribe or deliver vaccinations to client populations by protocol without direct physician involvement at the time of the interaction.

Settings include clinics, hospitals, and nursing homes.

(Dedicated vaccination clinics often operate under standing orders, but these were not considered to be an intervention for the purposes of this chapter.)

Provider education only

Insufficient evidence*

Provides information to vaccination providers to increase their knowledge or change attitudes.

Techniques can include written materials, lectures, continuing medical education programs, and computerized software.

* A determination that evidence is insufficient should not be confused with evidence of ineffectiveness. A determination of insufficient evidence assists in identifying (a) areas of uncertainty regarding effectiveness of an intervention and (b) specific continuing research needs. In contrast evidence of ineffectiveness leads to a recommendation that the intervention not be used.

  • See the full chapter as released by Task Force on Community Preventive Services in The Community Guide.